A tale of two headlines
A tale of two headlines
)

For weeks, the media displayed rare sympathy for two men, Andrew Chan and Myuran Sukumaran, who have now been executed in Indonesia. Rare indeed. It was an outpouring of humanisation and understanding that is almost never extended to the downtrodden in our society – not to refugees, not to Aboriginal people, not to Muslims accused of plotting terrorism, not to unionists and certainly not to convicted criminals.

On 30 April, Sydney’s Daily Telegraph ran a front page branding Indonesian president Joko Widodo “cruel” and an article labelling the executions “an act of barbarity … the brutal torture and state sanctioned murder of two Australian citizens in a foreign field”.

But nine years ago, when the death sentence was first handed down to Chan and Sukumaran, the Daily Telegraph was singing a rather different, and more familiar, tune. On 15 February 2006, its front page read: “NO SYMPATHY: Their drug operation would have destroyed thousands of lives – now they’ll pay with theirs.”

It’s a dramatic example of the sheer cynicism of the media, not to mention the politicians who have echoed their line. The right suffered a minor identity crisis over the executions.

On one hand, it is embedded in its DNA to promote a vicious, lynch mob, “shoot the bastards” law and order agenda, especially when the perpetrators are brown-skinned. On the other hand, it can’t pass up an opportunity to whip up a patriotic frenzy around the popular theme: civilised, modern Australia versus barbaric, backward foreigners.

People are right to oppose the death penalty, but the selective outrage from the media was not about humanitarian sentiment. It was about nationalism – and selling papers.

Read more
Socialist breakthrough in Victoria
Sarah Garnham

“Win, lose or draw, I could not be prouder of the campaign we’ve all been part of.” Jerome Small, Victorian Socialists candidate for the Northern Metropolitan region, summed it up well to an elated, exhausted crowd of hundreds at the Victorian Socialists’ post-election party. Throughout months of campaigning, it felt like we were having an impact, connecting with people who feel abandoned by the major parties, angry at the system and open to socialist solutions. As the results came trickling in on election night, we knew this feeling was right.

Analysing the Victorian election
Mick Armstrong

Despite a frenzied media barrage by the Murdoch press against “Dictator Dan”, Labor had a decisive victory in the Victorian election. Murdoch’s Herald Sun flirted with the politics of the far-right, anti-vax, conspiracy theory nutjobs to attack Premier Daniel Andrews, and the Liberal Party was happy to follow along.

The scandal of Indigenous children in detention
The scandal of Indigenous detention
Kim Bullimore

Six years after exposing the appalling treatment of Indigenous children in the Northern Territory’s Dondale prison, ABC’s Four Corners has revealed similarly terrible conditions in Western Australia’s Banksia Hill Juvenile Detention Centre. 

China’s COVID-19 crisis
China’s COVID-19 crisis
Robert Narai

A surge in both COVID-19 cases and protests inside China presents a dilemma for the ruling Communist Party. 

An election campaign in five convos
Jerome Small

I’ve loved being a candidate in the Victorian election. 

NDIS fails people with disabilities
Sandra Bloodworth

News that the annual cost of the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) is predicted to reach $50 billion in 2025-26 has caused much handwringing in Canberra and in the media. So much that NDIS Minister Bill Shorten has announced a review of waste in the scheme.