Skip to content

Remembering the Santa Cruz massacre

Thirty-five years ago, Indonesian elite Kopassus troops opened fire on a peaceful procession in Dili, the capital of then Indonesian-occupied East Timor (today known as Timor Leste), killing hundreds.

Remembering the Santa Cruz massacre
Image of Santa Cruz massacre. CREDIT: Max Stahl.

Thirty-five years ago, Indonesian elite Kopassus troops opened fire on a peaceful procession in Dili, the capital of then Indonesian-occupied East Timor (today known as Timor Leste), killing hundreds. The Indonesian generals responsible have never faced justice, protected by the Western governments who armed them and abetted their crimes. 

The procession, on the morning of 12 November 1991, followed a memorial mass at Motael Church for Sebastião Gomes Rangel, a young Timorese man killed by Indonesian security forces two weeks earlier. As the procession of 3,000 mourners made its way to Santa Cruz cemetery, pro-independence banners and flags were unfurled. Minutes after the crowd arrived at the cemetery, troops opened fire without warning.

Shooting continued as people tried to scale the cemetery’s high walls. Some were shot in the back while running away. Others while seeking shelter behind tombstones or in the cemetery’s chapel. More were stabbed and shot as they lay on the ground in pools of blood. According to survivor testimonies, dozens more were executed or disappeared after being taken to the Wira Husada Military Hospital. 

At least 271 East Timorese were killed that day, and an equal number disappeared, believed dead, according to the East Timor Action Network.

Australian foreign minister Gareth Evans was quick to defend Indonesia’s military, which had invaded East Timor in December 1975 and maintained a brutal occupation of the former Portuguese colony. A month after the massacre, Evans told parliament that while the incident was “‘deplorable”, it “was not ... a calculated or deliberate act of the [Indonesian] government as such”. Rather, it was “the product of aberrant behaviour by a subgroup within the country”. 

Two years earlier, Evans had joined his Indonesian counterpart, Ali Alatas, to toast the signing of the Timor Gap Treaty in a plane above the Timor Sea. With a glass of champagne in his hand, Evans declared: “This is a uniquely historical moment that is truly, uniquely historical”.

The treaty, several years in the making, carved up the rich oil and gas resources beneath the Timor Sea and opened the way for their exploitation by Australian resource companies. 

The Santa Cruz massacre was not unique. Many had preceded it, including the Kraras massacres, in the southern municipality of Viqueque in 1983. Prabowo Subianto, a rising star in the army and the son-in-law of Indonesian dictator, General Suharto, commanded the Kopassus special forces unit responsible. 

The Kraras massacres have been compared with the US army’s massacre of Vietnamese civilians in the village of Mai Lai in 1968. Much like the strategy pursued by Israel in Gaza and Lebanon, such attacks sought to isolate combatants via major military operations that killed and displaced large numbers of civilians.

In 2005, East Timor’s Truth and Reconciliation Commission (CAVR) concluded that Indonesia’s 24-year-long occupation resulted in between 102,800 and 183,000 conflict-related deaths, alongside widespread systematic torture, unlawful killings, enforced disappearances, forced displacement, and sexual violence. Many human rights organisations, including Genocide Watch, argue that Indonesia committed a genocide in East Timor.

What made the 1991 Santa Cruz massacre different from those that preceded it was that it was caught on film. When British cameraman Max Stahl’s footage was subsequently broadcast, it shone a light on Indonesia’s crimes and revived a global solidarity movement.

In Australia in the 1990s, socialists led a campaign group called Action in Solidarity with Indonesia and East Timor (ASIET), which coordinated demonstrations in conjunction with other East Timor solidarity groups across the country to commemorate the Santa Cruz massacre on 12 November each year.

We argued that the overthrow of Indonesia’s military dictatorship would open the road to Timorese independence, and that we therefore needed to support not only the resistance to the occupation, but also the growing student and worker movements in Indonesia that were calling for an end to Suharto’s military rule. We demanded that our own government break military ties with Indonesia.

Military and diplomatic ties between the two countries were extensive and growing, and by 1996 included a military pact. At the time, Australia was training Kopassus forces at the Kokoda Barracks on the Gold Coast. The Keating government also shamefully (and hypocritically) denied protection visas to East Timorese asylum seekers on the grounds that they were entitled to Portuguese citizenship.

The close Canberra-Jakarta relationship was staunchly defended in the Australian media. Writing in the Sydney Morning Herald on 9 December 1994, right-wing columnist Padraic (Paddy) McGuiness declared that “the alleged ‘genocide’ of the East Timorese population is a myth, assiduously cultivated by the propagandists and their dupes”.

These arguments would be familiar to anyone who has been involved in opposing Israel’s Gaza genocide.

In May 1998, Suharto was overthrown amidst a deep financial crisis. His successor, B.J. Habibi, was now forced to make concessions to the insurgent, student-led pro-democracy movement. General Prabowo stood accused of responsibility for the kidnapping and torturing pro-democracy Indonesian activists in Jakarta in the preceding months. Thirteen were forcibly disappeared, never to be seen again. 

Having now lost his protection, Prabowo was thrown out of the army. Habibi also reluctantly agreed to grant East Timorese a referendum on their future. In August 1999, they voted overwhelmingly for independence, despite a violent campaign of intimidation by the Indonesian military, including a series of brutal massacres. 

Under growing international pressure, Indonesia was forced to abandon its military occupation and hand control of the territory to a UN occupation force, known as UNTAET. In May 2002, Timor Leste finally gained its formal independence.

While Suharto’s overthrow led to a period of reformasi—democratic elections took place for the first time in 30 years—today, the military is back in business in Jakarta. Prabowo has not only escaped justice. He is now Indonesia’s president. 

And in Timor Leste, a nation desperate for foreign investment, former resistance leaders Xanana Gusmao and José Ramos Horta, now prime minister and president, routinely roll out the red carpet for Indonesian dignitaries, including former generals.

The Santa Cruz massacre is a reminder that justice is at best momentary and fleeting in a world carved up into spheres of interest between competing imperial powers. 

In 1961, observing the process of decolonisation in Africa, Franz Fanon wrote in the Wretched of the Earth: “The apotheosis of independence is transformed into the curse of independence, and the colonial power through its immense resources of coercion condemns the young nation to regression”.

In other words, without dismantling the system of oppression that binds us all, independence means little more than a flag and an anthem. 

Nick is the former Brisbane Coordinator for Action in Solidarity with Indonesia and East Timor 

More in Asia Pacific

See all
Emergency and autocracy in Modi’s India

Emergency and autocracy in Modi’s India

/
China’s forgotten miracle makers

China’s forgotten miracle makers

/

More from Nick Everett

See all