Western Australian youth detainees set fire to prison after suffering abuse

Prisoners inside Western Australia’s only youth detention centre, Banksia Hill, heralded the new year with an act of resistance—burning a building to the ground and climbing to the top of the prison’s perimeter fence. A look into the daily conditions faced by these young people, many of them Indigenous, shows why they would want to fight back against this horrendous institution.

Last November, the ABC’s Four Corners program put a spotlight on the mistreatment of inmates at Banksia Hill. It showed disturbing footage of guards brutalising children, holding them face down and bending their legs backwards in a position known as hog-tying or “folding up”. This practice has been banned in other states because it carries the risk of suffocation and death. In one recording, a boy can be heard crying out “I can’t breathe” while being forcefully held down by five officers.

Children at Banksia Hill are regularly placed in solitary confinement. A recent Supreme Court ruling against the WA government found that on 26 occasions a boy was unlawfully confined to his cell for more than twenty hours a day. 

One ex-detainee spoke to Four Corners about his torturous experience. Children who misbehave or try to harm themselves are sent to what is preposterously called the “intensive support unit”. He described hearing other inmates crying out “I want to kill myself” and getting no response. “You got no one to talk to, basically looking at four walls and after a while it will slowly get to you. The support for boys trying to harm themselves is the lowest it could be.”

There had been 32 suicide attempts within the year at the time of the report’s release.

Another ex-detainee talked about the blatant racism shown by guards, who called Indigenous inmates “b**ngs, black c***s, apes and monkeys”. Sixty three percent of inmates are Indigenous, despite making up only 3.3 percent of the Western Australian population. A 2018 study by the Telethon Institute found that 89 percent of youth detainees in WA had a severe cognitive impairment, and the rate of foetal alcohol spectrum disorder was the highest of any prison environment in the world. 

The whole system is designed to target the most disadvantaged children in society, punish them for lashing out and then traumatise them further. 

“The children of Banksia are our most impoverished, most traumatised children”, writes trauma recovery advocate Gerry Georgatos in an opinion piece for Independent Australia. “The majority were without a chance at a good life from the beginning—born into multiple disadvantages and cruel unfairness.” He describes Banksia Hill as “a corral of human misery”.

How has the Western Australian Labor government responded to the conditions in the centre? When riots occurred last year (a signal that detainees were suffering) the Department of Corrective Services sent the “worst offenders” to a maximum security adult prison. The government has continued to defend the decision despite widespread criticism. 

When Four Corners reporter Grace Tobin asked Corrective Services Minister Bill Johnston if he knew what folding up was, he denied any knowledge of the practice and distanced himself from the mistreatment of kids in detention, arguing: “I’m the minister. I don’t personally work in the custodial estate, I’m not a youth custodial officer. Of course it’s not reasonable for me to know the specific details of any allegations that might be made by a young offender”. 

The government has come under increased fire since the Four Corners program aired. In an effort to neutralise the growing criticism, Premier Mark McGowan announced a $63 million funding boost for Banksia Hill, half of which would go towards infrastructure upgrades, including the strengthening of security to control “high risk and difficult” detainees. The announcement was criticised by Aboriginal community leaders and human rights advocates, with the co-chair of Social Reinvestment WA and CEO of the Wungening Aboriginal Corporation, Daniel Morrison, dismissing it as a media stunt, telling the Guardian that if the premier “put half as much energy into actually fixing the issues, we would all be in a better place, including the children without a voice”. 

The events of new year’s eve confirm that the conditions have not changed. Where there are riots, there is suffering and desperation. Banksia Hill is a racist disgrace where the systematic torture of vulnerable kids takes place. Justice won’t be served until the whole facility is destroyed and those who run it are charged with child abuse.

Read more
Refugees organise a week of protest
Renee Nayef 

Hundreds of refugees rallied outside Home Affairs Minister Clare O’Neil’s office in Oakleigh, in south-east Melbourne, on Monday, demanding permanent visas for those who have still not gained protection more than a year after the election of the federal Labor government. 

The revolt in Iran, one year on
Bella Beiraghi

The murder of 22-year-old Kurdish woman Mahsa Amini at the hands of Iran’s morality police last September sparked the largest revolt in Iran since the 1979 revolution. What began as a protest in Gina Mahsa Amini’s home town of Saqqez soon developed into a nationwide revolt against the Iranian state. Over the course of six months, hundreds of thousands of students, workers, the young and the old, took to the streets with the battle cry “Jin, Jiyan, Azadi!” (Women, life, freedom). 

Abolish the GST!
Abolish the GST!
Duncan Hart

Australia’s goods and services tax is the one tax that the rich in this country love. 

‘The people want the fall of the regime!’
Interview: Syria erupts again
Omar Hassan

Large demonstrations have been taking place across Syria in recent weeks. While their scale has yet to reach the peaks seen in 2011, many are hopeful that the government will be brought down. To get a more detailed assessment of the movement and the situation it faces in Syria, Red Flag spoke to long-time Syrian leftist Jamal Chamma. Jamal is based in Melbourne and has been involved for years in organising demonstrations in solidarity with the Syrian revolution.

Falling real wages the problem
Liam Parry

Treasurer Jim Chalmers claimed last week that the average Australian worker is $3,700 “better off” than a year ago, citing this as proof that Labor in government has delivered on its promise to “get wages moving again”. The West Australian newspaper called it “Labor’s wages growth win”. Other media headlines could almost have tricked you into thinking that workers are getting richer right now.

Why the left should vote Yes
Jordan Humphreys

As the referendum approaches, the key dynamic in the debate is clear. The conservative right views a defeat for the Voice as a chance to strike a devastating blow against support for Indigenous rights among the Australian population. In the process, it is reviving every racist myth in the play book: Indigenous people shouldn’t get “special privileges”; opposing anti-Aboriginal racism is actually “dividing the nation”; and the colonisation of Australia had only a “positive impact”, in the words of Jacinta Price.