Skip to content

One Nation is waging war on progress. Why won't progressives fight back?

Today, the snarling menace and enemy of workers and the left that is One Nation is a major force in Victoria; it enjoys mass support, is vying for lower house seats, and setting the agenda in the state election campaign. Progressive Victoria should be in uproar.

One Nation is waging war on progress. Why won't progressives fight back?
One Nation Senator Pauline Hanson. CREDIT: AAP/Lukas Coch.

In 2018, One Nation struggled to get registered as a political party in Victoria, and progressives across the state took pride in it. Labor won the state election that year with a whopping 43 percent primary vote. Twenty years earlier, One Nation leader Pauline Hanson had been prevented from organising in Melbourne by protests, blockades and community events.

Today, the snarling menace and enemy of workers and the left that is One Nation is a major force in Victoria; it enjoys mass support, is vying for lower house seats, and setting the agenda in the state election campaign. The party and its policies have been legitimised by the capitalist press, the Liberal Party and, to a lesser extent, Labor. One Nation’s Victorian leader, Warren Pickering, has been invited to appear at the leaders’ debate.  

Progressive Victoria should be in uproar. This is the state of Trades Hall, Treaty and Pride. But aside from a few important exceptions—most notably high school students—the response to One Nation’s rise has been decidedly muted. Progressive NGOs and organisations have mostly stayed silent or offered tepid statements focusing on the fears of their constituents rather than forthright denunciation of One Nation and all it represents. The mood is closer to stunned awe than anger, almost as if the capacity to generate the ever-more-elusive commodity of popularity makes a party worthy of respect, however the popularity might be gained. 

Worse still, a layer of trade union organisers, Greens members and other progressives is arguing that the left must sympathise with the concerns of One Nation voters, or at least avoid antagonising them through political argument. In practice, this means sidestepping the signature issues that One Nation is pushing and building a base around. 

GetUp and Victorian Trades Hall Council (VTHC) are directing campaigners not to “play the racism card” or explicitly attack Pauline Hanson. After its costly and high-profile intervention in the Farrer by-election, GetUp concluded that criticising Hanson, her wealthy backer Gina Rinehart, celebrity defector Barnaby Joyce or the party’s links to Trump is not electorally expedient. Campaigners should instead seek to establish common ground with potential One Nation voters based on economic grievances. 

Senior VTHC researcher Oscar Kaspi-Crutchett argues to ignore the politics: “Don’t listen to the lyrics, listen to the beat of what they are saying”. The beat, he says, is dissatisfaction with the status quo, so supporters should be helped to “tease out” what that looks like and how it makes them feel. 

Federal Greens leader David Shoebridge says he has “understood the anger” driving One Nation support. Former Queensland Greens MP Max Chandler-Mathers goes further, arguing that One Nation voters, especially the workers among them, are expressing legitimate protest against the system. He says they are driven by an “almost political nihilism”, and a desire to “blow it up” that makes them open to left-wing arguments and solutions. 

The same basic approach is being taken by more establishment political forces. Teal consultant Sue Barret gives the same advicein four steps: validate the feeling, not the target; ask a genuine question and then be quiet; acknowledge the ground you share; offer a different path, not a different diagnosis.

Labor’s federal treasurer likewise warns progressives not to “scold” One Nation supporters, and to approach them “from a place of genuine respect and understanding”. The same advice is given by the media, from the establishment right through to liberal outlets. And all of this helps to reinforce One Nation’s spin about itself: that it is the party of “everyday Australians” who are “sick and tired of being ignored”. 

This appeasement goes further than merely tempering criticisms of One Nation for fear of alienating the party’s voters; it leads to actively opposing efforts to build resistance. 

The Labor-controlled National Union of Students, for example, pulled out of supporting the second student walkout against One Nation, and attacked office bearers for promoting it. Some Greens MPs have endorsed and spoken at the rallies, but others refused to speak on the grounds that it is not strategic and would alienate bigots. When a socialist promoted an anti-One Nation rally in a union activist online forum, the Victorian secretary of the CPSU and long-time leftist Jiselle Hanna replied that it is “more powerful to understand why so many of the working class are being persuaded by One Nation, than dismissing them all as a bunch of racists”. She then removed unionists who backed the protest from the forum.

What is going on?

For some, the lack of interest in denouncing or confronting far-right supporters today comes from a sense of defeatism: One Nation is connecting with the moment better than our side of politics, so we have no credibility to challenge it. Unfortunately, this only leads to further normalisation of the right and the further weakening of our side. 

For others, it may be that they see protest and other forms of resistance aimed at polarising sentiment as an outdated method. Yet history is full of successful movements against the far right. In the 1990s, mass and sustained demonstrations helped push One Nation back to the margins. Last month in Serbia, a two-year, student-led protest movement ended the rule of a right-wing nationalist government. Even if the far right can’t be defeated immediately, efforts towards building mass resistance have more to recommend them than cowering passivity.

But by far the most pervasive argument made by progressives is that One Nation voters are confused victims of the system and therefore potentially open to influence. The stereotype of the everyday person fed up with official politics, the major parties and motivated primarily by their bread-and-butter concerns, is the common-sense explanation of the rise of the “populist” right in Australia as well as many other places. 

Commentators across the political spectrum have their own version of it, with flourishes based on their particular political outlook. Right-wing journalist Phil Coorey says people are pining for an Australia before multiculturalism and “elite progressivism”. Labor-aligned Kos Samaras says they are the victims of disintegrating local community, health and public services. Chandler-Mathers says the hollowing-out of collective organisation has “left a febrile and unstable political democracy because now the vast majority of people are completely disconnected from either major party”, with housing and financial stress as the spark.

But as French anti-fascist writer Andrew Hussey has noted, “populism” is a dubious label. It is applied to parties of the right in a way that reflects “the elitist prejudice that the people are ignorant and irrational, impulsive and incoherent, easily manipulated and prone to authoritarian excess and frenzies of xenophobia”. Political disengagement is high, and incoherence is its corollary, but the idea that One Nation voters cannot meaningfully be associated with the party’s actual politics is misorienting.

It is these politics that matter the most. The reasons why people might vote for One Nation do not determine what it stands for. And there is little ambiguity on this score: a new White Australia, mass deportations, attacks on workers’ rights, more freedom for business, fewer environmental protections and more power for the state to lock people up and repress dissent.

Like its counterparts worldwide, its program is a reaction to every progressive advance since the last major wave of struggle in the 1960s and ’70s, dressed up as no-nonsense common sense. It defines itself against pro-Palestine sentiment, migrant and refugee rights, strong unions, women’s rights, trans inclusion, net zero and public health measures. It opposes these not because they are aspects of a neoliberal status quo, but because they represent the agenda of the left and the working-class movement. 

One Nation sees the major parties as having bowed to these “woke” demands and is open about its intention to reverse them. Whatever individual voters feel, this is the goal of the party and the corporate donors that bankroll it. This is what distinguishes it from all the other parties. And it’s why One Nation has made the greatest gains when political developments have favoured this reactionary agenda. Indeed, the party’s key breakthrough from the margins to the mainstream came following the Bondi massacre, when anti-Muslim, anti-migrant, ultra-nationalist sentiment was at a righteous high.

A preoccupation with sugar-coating the support base of One Nation, and the assumption underlying it that One Nation supporters are uniquely disconnected from the formal politics of the party for some unexplained reason, has the effect of downplaying the importance of One Nation’s formal politics and the threat they pose. The beneficiaries of this emphasis are those, like the Labor Party, wanting to adopt elements of One Nation’s policies, whether because they have no alternative agenda to argue convincingly for, they want to chase the right-wing vote or because they recognise that many in the capitalist class approve of those policies, and that’s what matters to them. 

These forces will do anything to avoid admitting that a significant section of the population has been won over to supporting a fascist-adjacent political machine. To do so means facing up to the inherent responsibility to resist.     

So what should we do?

First, we need to acknowledge that One Nation is a reactionary blight on society. To confront it, we need to have two approaches simultaneously. The first is to build opposition to One Nation in the here and now, by being clear and firm about how reactionary the party is and by mobilising and giving confidence to those already hostile to it. The second is the longer-term project of rebuilding a strong left, tied to a powerful workers’ movement, on the scale needed to decisively set the far right back. Those arguing for pandering to One Nation supporters are working towards neither. 

Chandler-Mathers argues for a Greens program of “progressive populism”, to be presented via one-on-one conversations that don’t challenge voters’ diagnosis of the problems with the system but offer alternative policies, such as better services, welfare and wealth redistribution. He regularly cites anecdotes to endorse this approach, for instance winning a One Nation voter to the Greens by explaining their free lunches program. For him and others on the Greens’ left, this strategy is the bedrock of an ambition to electorally replace Labor. 

The unions offer a similar approach: one-on-one conversations with workers flirting with the right, focused on Hanson’s anti-worker record, with a vote for Labor as the hopeful outcome. They refuse to hold Labor responsible for attacks on the working class—even unions that have scaled back their campaigning efforts in the Victorian election still orient to it and lobby it. The VTHC pamphlet by Kaspi-Crutchett, Antidote: trade unionism as a vaccine against far-right politics, argues that unions offer workers a better cultural home and identity, and that union membership correlates with voting Labor. It says a lot about the movement’s low horizons that the pamphlet makes no case for industrial struggle and power, either to win working-class demands or to build support for working-class politics.

For socialists, politics isn’t about offering a program to a passive public. It isn’t about convincing individuals to vote for what we decide is good for them. It is about winning arguments at a deeper level, to actually change people’s worldview to one of recognising working-class interests and power. And it is about building a movement that can impose that worldview on society, that can chalk up wins for workers and the oppressed, and demonstrate in practice that the left has the answers. Elections are part of that, but left electoral programs will only be truly effective as an extension of existing class power and organisation. 

If we did have a strong fighting left and union movement right now, it would be possible to make a meaningful dent in the momentum of the far right. We could have mass protests against racism, in support of migrant rights and demonstrations of solidarity between workers across racial lines. Unions could arrest the cost-of-living crisis, win higher wages for particular groups of workers and force broader social gains like price controls, interest payment freezes and more funding for services. We could extend the Palestine movement to force the government to break ties with Israel and build a powerful anti-war movement against AUKUS and the US alliance. We could stop the construction of AI data centres, force the government to build public housing and put the environment before the profits of fossil fuel companies. We could put black bans on projects connected to Rinehart, Musk or any far-right figures here or globally, and organise hospitality staff and others to ensure Hanson and her cronies can’t meet in peace anywhere, as happened in the movement against the apartheid South African Springbok tour.

This is the kind of power and momentum the left needs to strive to build. Such a movement would then open the way to arguing with reactionary layers and with workers who hold backward ideas, both by having a bigger platform from which to attack their politics and through our ability to impose ours. A serious working-class force could also pose real solutions to most grievances—not as a defensive offering in exchange for a vote, but as an alternative to dog-eat-dog capitalism. In this context, sections of the middle class, such as small business owners, can be won to a program that disciplines the big capitalists and provides welfare for all.

This also raises the question of power. If the collective organisation of workers, in bodies like workplace and strike committees, can win gains, why not maintain them as day-to-day governing bodies rather than just defensive organisations? This starts to become a challenge to the power of the capitalist class in its entirety and raises the possibility of a different type of society based on direct democratic control of society’s wealth: socialism.

We are a long way from such a movement. The long-term degeneration of the unions and the left means we lack the forces, influence and capacity to initiate the struggle that is needed, and the right far outnumbers us. It has international and domestic conditions in its favour and will remain a serious force for the medium term, whatever One Nation’s exact electoral results. History offers no blueprint for stopping the far right’s momentum, though successful anti-fascist movements contain many lessons. But we have to keep in our sights the scale of the movement and organised force needed to push it back.

We have to start somewhere. That means building among people who are horrified by One Nation and can recognise it for what it is, and drawing them together to act, organising protests and resistance, and by putting our political opposition to the far right front and centre. Our dealings with the far right should be about confronting and denouncing its politics, not excusing it through sympathy with its supporters, or nodding along when they scapegoat their migrant neighbours. 

The far right have in part been successful because they know their enemy and fight it ruthlessly. They do not focus on how misunderstood and decent left-wing people are. They detest us and everything we stand for, and use that hatred to build. We need to do the same.

Beyond organising opposition to the far right, we need to build the power and institutions of our side generally. The organised socialist movement is the force that can draw together the immediate and long-term tasks we face: that can offer staunch and principled opposition to the far right today, and that can work towards the kind of power and struggle necessary to defeat it and the entire system that breeds it.

More in Australia

See all

More from Sarah Garnham

See all
Business community has a big sook

Business community has a big sook

/